Chapter 9 of 10 · 9 min read
Other People
From The Practical Art of Living Free by Wrotebook
Jo rang her brother from the stationery cupboard, at ten past one on a Monday in March, with twenty minutes of lunch left and a box of glue sticks at her elbow. She had chosen the time with care. In the evening she would have been tired, and he would have heard a complaint. On a Sunday she would have been angry. At ten past one on a Monday she was only a teacher with a list, which was the person she needed to be.
"Jo? What's happened? Is it Mum?"
"Nothing's happened. Mum's fine. That's why I'm ringing now and not from A&E."
There was a pause, and behind it the sound of an office in Leeds.
"Right," Martin said. "Okay. What's up?"
She had written it on the back of a seating plan, because she knew herself; left to improvise, she would hint. She had been hinting for three years. She had said that it had been a long week, and that Mum was asking after him, and that she didn't suppose he was over this way at all. Martin, who was not a bad man, had heard a sister who was tired and coping, and had said he must get across soon. Hints had let both of them pretend that nothing was being asked.
"I need you to take Sundays," she said. "With Mum. Every Sunday, the whole day, starting this week."
"This Sunday?"
"This Sunday."
"Every week, though. Jo, Sundays are the boys' football, and we've got—"
"I know. I've got Ella's exams, and Ben, and a hundred and eighty books a week, and I've been round there four times since Friday. I'm not ringing to tell you I'm busier than you are. I'm ringing because I'm doing all of it and I can't, and I'd rather ask you now than start hating you. I don't want to hate you. You're my brother."
The office noise went on for some time.
"I didn't know it was four times."
"You didn't ask, and I didn't tell you. That's both of us."
"I thought you had it all in hand. You always seem to."
"I did have it in hand. That's the trouble with having things in hand. Nobody ever takes them off you."
He tried, as she had known he would, to make it smaller. Could it be alternate Sundays? Could he pay for somebody to go in? She said that their mother did not want a stranger on a Sunday, she wanted her son, and that Jo did not want money, she wanted a day.
"Every Sunday's a lot," Martin said.
"Yes, it is. It's a seventh of what I'm doing."
She heard him breathe out.
"All right. Sundays. I'll be there at ten."
"And you have to tell her yourself. If it comes from me, it's me getting rid of her."
Pat was furious, with a thoroughness that took in both her children. She did not need a rota. She was not a parcel. She had managed perfectly well for seventy-nine years. On the Tuesday she told Jo that she had gone behind her back, and on the Wednesday she told Martin that he needn't trouble himself. He came on the Sunday at ten regardless, with a newspaper and a shop-bought lemon cake, which she pronounced dry. By the third Sunday she had a list of jobs waiting for him. By the fifth she had had her hair done on the Saturday. In April she remarked to Jo, as if passing on news, that Martin had been explaining his work to her, which she had never understood, and that he was not as daft as he looked.
The first of Jo's free Sundays was not a success. She woke at seven braced for the drive, remembered, and spent the day ironing and waiting for the phone, which rang twice, both times with Martin asking where things were kept. On the second she marked books. It was the third before she did anything that could be called her own, which was to sit in the garden in her coat for an hour with a mug of tea, looking at the bed where things once grew.
What Jo did in the stationery cupboard was not to love her mother less. Nothing about the tie was loosened. What changed was that it acquired an edge, a day on which the caring was someone else's to do, and it is the edge that will allow her to go on. Care with no limit has a short life. It runs for a few years on love and then for a few more on guilt, and when it ends, it tends to end in illness or in bitterness. A limit is what turns such a duty into something that can be carried for twenty years. The overcommitted carer, to give Jo's condition its name, has too much of nothing except solitude, and the remedy lies in other people.
She also gave something away without meaning to. For three years her competence had kept Martin from his own mother. He had been excused, and being excused from someone is one way of losing them. The Sundays cost him his weekends and gave him back a parent while there was still time to know her, and neither of them would have thought to describe that as a favour when she rang.
If there is a Martin somewhere in your own arrangements, the lesson of the cupboard is in its mechanics. She asked for one specific thing, with a day of the week and a starting date attached. She asked the person who could give it, directly, at an hour when she was calm. She did not argue from who was busier. She turned down the smaller substitute when it was offered. And she left him a task, the telling of their mother, which made the arrangement his as well as hers. A hint asks for nothing and so cannot be refused. A request can be, which is why it is frightening to make and why it works.
Not every Martin says yes. Jo had rehearsed that as well: had he refused, she would at least have learned how things stood, and her next call would have been to find out what help the council and the surgery could offer. And some ties fail the test of this chapter outright. A relationship held together by fear of the other person is no kind of chosen gravity. It is captivity of the plainest sort, the word for what it needs is not renegotiation, and anyone inside one deserves help in getting out.
Callum and Sam met in Castle Park on a Saturday later that month, on a bench above the water, because Sam had said somewhere outside, I'm not doing this in your kitchen. He arrived with two coffees and a strong sense of having been summoned.
"I'm going to ask you something," Sam said, "and I'd like you not to be charming about it."
"That's quite limiting."
"I know. What are we?"
He had the answers ready, as he had for two years: we're good, we're us, why does it need a word. He could feel them forming a queue.
"I'm not asking for a ring. I'm asking so that I know what to tell people. My sister asks. My mother has stopped asking, which is worse. I've been patient, and I want you to know that it's running out. I don't mean it as a threat. It's just information, like a fuel gauge."
Callum looked at the water. "Can I say what I'm scared of first?"
"If it's short."
"If I say what I want, then it's a thing. And then it can go wrong. If I never say it, then nobody can take anything off me."
"Nobody can give you anything, either," Sam said. "I've been trying to give you the contents of one drawer for a year."
He laughed before he could help it, and then stopped, because it was true.
"Okay," he said. "What I want." It came out more slowly than anything he had said in years. "I want to be with you, and I want that to be the fact and not the working assumption. I want to go to your sister's and be introduced as something. I want us to live in the same place. Not next week. But I want that to be where this is going, and I want you to be able to say that I said so. And I want you to have the drawer. Both drawers. I'll get a shelf."
Sam said nothing for a moment.
"That's the first sentence with 'want' in it I've ever heard you say."
"There were several."
"I counted four." Sam drank some coffee. "And Portugal?"
"You know about Portugal?"
"Callum, there's a folder on your desktop called Portugal."
He took a while over that one. "I don't know. I've looked at those houses for three years and I've never once rung anybody. I don't think I can tell you what it is until I find out what one of them would actually take."
"Then find out. I'm not afraid of a house. I was afraid of a folder."
Sam took out a phone. "I'm telling my sister we're coming on the fourteenth. I'm doing it now, while you're sitting here, so that you can stop me."
He did not stop it.
The life Callum had been living has a name among the ways of failing to be free, and the name is the private island: independence without belonging. On an island nobody can make demands of you. Nobody turns up unannounced, expects you on Sunday or wants to know where things stand, and for the same reason nobody brings you soup. He had taken this for the opposite of Nadia's cage, when it was the same enclosure with the door on the other side. She could not get out of her obligations. He could not get in to any. Both were being governed by fear, hers of having too little and his of being held to something, and a life run on fear is not free whichever way it happens to be running.
It is a fair test of any close tie to ask what it runs on. Some run on fear, of being left or of being alone. Some run on guilt, as Jo's care had begun to: not the wish to be there but the dread of what it would mean if she were not. Some run on performance, on being agreeable and easy and asking for nothing, which was the fuel of Callum's two years of warm answers. Ties like these can last a long time, and they wear down the people in them. The other kind is easy to recognise once you have seen it. Each person can do more, and risk more, and say more that is true, because the other is there. Sam's steadiness is what made it possible for Callum to decide something. Martin's Sundays freed his sister and, less obviously, himself.
The audit's last question is the one that matters most here, and it is the only one that some relationships can pass. On cost, Pat fails, as does every child ever born and most marriages in their difficult decades. Gravity asks something else: whether the pull is chosen, whether it is honest, and whether it is worth tending. Jo would choose her mother again without a second's thought. What she would not choose again is to do it alone and in silence, and the audit's word for what she did about that is renegotiate, which applies wherever a tie involves somebody else and its terms have stopped being fair. Callum's word is a heavier one. He made a promise, the first of his adult life, on a bench, in front of a witness who was counting.
Nadia's version was small, and it had happened back in November. On the evening before the glass meeting room she took the train to Marple, walked a mile of towpath with Yasmin in the dark, and told her what she was going to ask for. She told her sister before she had told anybody at the firm, and it was only afterwards that she saw why that had mattered. The first person you tell about a decision is the person your life answers to. For eleven years, in Nadia's case, that person had worked on the fourth floor.
"Thank God," Yasmin had said. "Does this mean I get you on Fridays?"
On the sixth of Martin's Sundays Jo was at home at eleven in the morning, in a quiet house, with Ella revising upstairs and nothing in particular to do, when her phone rang. It was her mother.
"Your brother has brought the wrong milk."
"Then tell him, Mum. Don't tell me."
"I have told him," said Pat, with satisfaction. "I'm telling you as well."