Chapter 5 of 10 · 9 min read
The Freedom Trap
From The Practical Art of Living Free by Wrotebook
Nadia keeps a spreadsheet called Out. It has seven tabs, and the first contains only two things: a sum of money in cell B2, in bold, and next to it a year, the one in which the sheet predicts that her savings will reach that sum and she can stop. She began it at thirty-three, after a week of fourteen-hour days, and she has opened it on perhaps one evening in three ever since. The year in the cell corresponds to her fifty-seventh birthday. According to a column she added in October, the director's salary would bring it down to her fifty-fifth.
Almost everyone in her office has some version of this file, whether or not they have typed it out. The promise it encodes is simple and, as promises go, respectable. Work hard now, harder than you would like. Spend less than you earn. Build the pot. Then, on a date you can calculate, walk out and begin to live. Its most disciplined followers have given it an acronym, FIRE, for financial independence, retire early, and they pursue it with savings rates that would alarm their grandparents.
At its best the idea asks a question that few other things in working life ask at all: how much of my life am I trading for money, and is the trade a good one? That question belongs in this book. So does a plain acknowledgement, before any criticism, of what saving is for. Poverty is not freedom, and there is nothing pure about precarity. A cushion is a form of liberty in its own right, since it is what lets a person refuse a bad boss, survive a broken boiler, or leave. Callum, with his six weeks of savings and a pension he has not looked at in seven years, is nobody's example of how to live free; he is one run of bad luck away from having no choices at all. Nothing in this chapter is an argument against putting money by, and none of it is advice about pensions or investments, on which anyone with a decision to make should consult a regulated adviser. The argument is narrower. It concerns what can happen to a life that is organised around the date.
What can happen is that the machine built to buy freedom starts to consume it, and Nadia's spreadsheet, read honestly, shows each of the ways.
The first is on tab one, beneath the date, where she keeps a list headed After. It includes the cello, a long-distance path she would like to walk, more time with her sister, Italian. The list has barely changed in eight years, and not one item on it is present in her life now, even in miniature. The assumption underneath is that these things are being stored somewhere and will be released, intact, on her fifty-seventh birthday. But a way of living is closer to a language than to a deposit, and it fades when it is not used. A person can leave work with plenty of money and no rhythm, no company, no skill and no nerve, and discover that the life she postponed for a quarter of a century is one she no longer knows how to lead.
The second is in the history of cell B2. Nadia has revised the sum upward four times, on each occasion after a pay rise. The rise improved her life a little: a better flat, the car, the cleaner, holidays chosen for speed of booking. The improved life then became the life she would need to fund for thirty years of retirement, and so the target grew. In six years her salary has risen by nearly a third and the date in the cell has not moved by a month. Every raise became a baseline, and a baseline has to be paid for twice, once now and once in the size of the pot.
The remaining tabs hold the third. She has a workplace pension, an older pension from a previous employer, two ISAs, a share scheme and some premium bonds, each with its own login, statement and small annual decision. She has considered a buy-to-let flat and has a tab for that too. None of these is foolish. Together they amount to a part-time job, done on Sunday afternoons, administering a freedom she does not yet have. Complexity creeps in the name of optimisation, and every extra moving part is one more thing with a call on her attention.
The fourth is an app on her phone that shows the value of her investments, which she checks more often than she would care to admit. In a bad week for the markets the date slides out by eight months, and her mood goes with it. In a good week she is buoyant for reasons that have nothing to do with anything she did. Her sense of how free she is has become a kind of weather, made somewhere else.
The fifth is the hardest to see, because it looks like its own opposite. Nadia thinks of the spreadsheet as her rebellion against work. But notice how she runs it. She measures. She optimises. She takes a moral satisfaction in sacrifice, and is as proud of her savings rate as she once was of her billable hours, for much the same reason. The goal has changed from promotion to exit, while the structure underneath is the one her job installed: worth through output, life as a project with a deliverable and a deadline. It is workism wearing a disguise, and the disguise is very good.
Taken together these explain something that puzzles people in Nadia's position, which is why the date never seems to get any nearer however well they do. The harder she works for it, the more compensation the work requires, the higher the baseline climbs, the larger the pot must be, and the harder she has to work.
There is an older and more useful piece of arithmetic. In 1992 Vicki Robin and Joe Dominguez published Your Money or Your Life, whose central idea is that money is something you receive in exchange for your life energy, the hours of the only life you have. It is a way of framing the matter and not a finding, but it comes with a calculation anyone can do. Work out your real hourly wage: take what the job actually pays you, subtract what the job costs you, and divide by all the hours it actually takes.
Here are Nadia's numbers. They are invented, as she is, and are offered as an illustration of the method and nothing more.
Her salary is £82,000 for a contracted week of thirty-seven and a half hours, which on paper is £42 an hour. After tax, National Insurance and her pension contribution she takes home about £55,700, or roughly £28.50 for each contracted hour. So far this is her payslip talking.
Now the hours. She does not work thirty-seven and a half; counting the evenings and the Sunday messages, she works about fifty. Her commute, door to desk and back, adds six a week. Then there is the hour each evening when she is home but fit for nothing, which exists because of the job and belongs in its column: five more. Sixty-one hours a week, over the forty-six weeks a year she is not on leave, comes to about 2,800 hours.
Next come the costs that would vanish if the job did. The tram is £1,300 a year. Work clothes and dry cleaning add £1,400. Lunches bought at her desk because there is no time to make them come to £1,900. The cleaner, whom she employs because she has no weekend left to clean in, costs £1,560, and the takeaways and taxis of the evenings when she is too tired to cook or wait for a tram cost about £2,000. Last comes the line she found hardest to write down, the spending she does because she has earned it, the hurried holidays and consoling purchases, which she put at £2,400. The total is £10,560.
Take that from £55,700 and divide what is left by 2,800 hours, and Nadia's real wage is a little over £16 an hour. She looked at the figure for some time. It did not make her poor, and it did not make her job a bad one. It told her the actual price at which she was selling her hours, which was well under half of what she had always supposed.
Then she ran the promotion through the same sum. Fourteen thousand pounds is about £8,100 after tax. The role would add, by her reckoning, some nine hours a week in early trains and late calls, a little over four hundred hours a year. The new hours would therefore pay her just under £20 each, before the extra taxis, and they would be drawn from the only part of her week that had not already been sold.
Try this with your own figures, whatever they are. The sum is the same on a wage of twelve pounds an hour as on Nadia's salary, and it tends to matter more, because the costs of holding down a job, the bus fares and childcare and food eaten on the move, take a larger bite out of a smaller wage. The purpose is not to make you resent your work. It is to let you see the exchange rate, so that the next time you are offered more money for more hours you will know what you are actually being offered.
One question is left, and the rest of this book leans on it. If you reached the number tomorrow, what would you do on Tuesday, and could you practise a small version of it now?
It has to be a Tuesday. The first week of freedom is easy to imagine and tells you nothing, being all sleep and airports. An ordinary Tuesday, at half past ten in the morning, with the washing done and nobody expecting you, is where a life either has a shape or does not. Most people can say at once what they would be escaping from. Far fewer can say what they would walk towards, and the difficulty of answering is itself the finding, because it suggests that the date has been standing in for a decision.
Nor does the question belong only to people with spreadsheets. Jo has no number and no date; a teacher's pension arrives when it arrives, and she could not afford to hurry it if she wanted to. Asked what she would do with a free Tuesday she would know at once, which is its own kind of information: she would be on a hillside with a fork in her hand, and the form that might one day put her there went into a post box in October. Her difficulty was never that she had postponed her life until some sum was reached. The life she wants and the life she has are both happening now, in the same seven days, and one of them keeps losing. For her the useful half of the question is the second half, about the small version, and what a small version could possibly look like in a week like hers is a matter for a later chapter and a good deal of help.
Nadia could not answer straight away either. Her first attempts were travel, which is not a Tuesday, and rest, which is not a life. It took her most of an evening to get to something true. She would play the cello in the morning, for an hour, badly at first; the instrument was still at the workshop in Chorlton, waiting for its bridge. And in the afternoon she would go for a long walk with her sister. Yasmin lives in Marple, twenty minutes away by train, and the two of them used to walk the canal towpath towards the hills for hours, talking about their father and about nothing, until Nadia's Saturdays filled up and the walks became something they said they must do again.
She looked at the two answers side by side, and what struck her was their price. A set of strings costs less than a client lunch. The train to Marple is a few pounds. Neither answer needed the fourteen thousand pounds, or two years off the date, or indeed the date. Both needed hours, and hours were the one thing the offer in her inbox proposed to take.
She did not decide anything that night. She opened Out, left the bold sum and the year exactly as they were, and added a row beneath the list headed After. In it she typed Tuesday: cello, a.m.; walk with Yas, p.m. The sheet has a column that works out, for every item on the list, the year in which she will be able to afford it. She dragged the formula down into the new row, and after a moment's thought it returned that day's date.