Chapter 6 of 10 · 9 min read
Enough Work
From The Practical Art of Living Free by Wrotebook
"I'd like to say no to director," Nadia said, "and ask you for something else instead."
It was the last Thursday in November, in the glass meeting room on the fourth floor, and the head of her practice had come in with the look of a man about to deliver good news for the second time. He put his coffee down.
"Is it the money? Because there's some room on the money."
"It isn't the money."
"Have you had an offer? If somebody's approached you, I'd much rather know."
"Nobody's approached me. I want to stay. I want to stay at my grade, on four days a week, with Fridays off, and I'll take the pay cut that goes with it."
He looked at her for a moment in the way people look at a column that will not add up. Then, more gently, he asked whether everything was all right at home. She said that everything was fine, and watched him put the question away unanswered, in the place where he kept things to come back to.
She had prepared it like a pitch, and she went through it like one. Four days at eighty per cent of salary. She would keep the first London account and hand back the second, which she had inherited eighteen months earlier and never formally been given. Her team would stay at seven. She would be reachable on a Friday in a real emergency, and they would agree beforehand what counted as one.
"Clients don't know it's Friday," he said.
"Clients don't know it's Sunday either, and we manage to hold that line. Mostly."
"I'll tell you what I've seen. I've seen four-day weeks. What happens is that people do five days' work in four, get paid for four, and then they're angry with me."
It was the best objection there was, and she had been waiting for it. "Then that's what a trial is for. Six months. If by June I'm doing five days in four, it's failed, and I'll be the one to say so."
There was one more thing, and he had the decency to put it plainly. Coming out of the January round was not a pause. Somebody else would get the seat. He could not promise there would be another round with her name in it, and some of the partners would read the four days as a statement about how serious she was.
"I know," Nadia said. "I've counted that."
He said he would have to take it to the partners and did not know what they would say. At the door he stopped. "For what it's worth, I think you'd have been good at it."
"So do I," she said, and that was the part it had taken her two months to be able to say.
The partners agreed the following week: six months from January, reviewed in June. That evening she went back to the message that had arrived at 4.47 on a Tuesday in September, which she had marked as unread so many times that its bold type had become a fixture of her inbox, and answered it at last, in three lines.
It is worth counting what she paid, since a decision like this is often described as though it were free. A fifth of her salary came to £16,400, or about £750 a month after tax. Set beside the offer she had turned down, the gap between the two futures was about £1,400 a month, every month, with a mortgage whose fixed rate was about to end. She had also spent some standing, which is harder to price. People who had assumed she was going up now did not know where she was going, and in a firm like hers that uncertainty has a cost of its own. Two colleagues asked her, separately and kindly, whether she was unwell. A third, who had wanted the director's seat for himself, thanked her with a warmth she would have preferred not to receive.
What she bought was forty-six Fridays a year. With the commute and the evening recovery that had gone with each working day, that was something over five hundred and fifty hours, and when she divided the money by the hours the result was about sixteen pounds for each one. She recognised the figure. It was the real hourly wage she had worked out a few weeks before. Pro rata, done honestly, means buying your hours back at the price you sell them for, and seen in that light she had not taken a pay cut so much as withdrawn a fifth of her stock from sale.
She could do it only because of what she had done first. Through November she lowered the cost of her month. The car went back, having been driven eleven times since June, and took with it a payment and an insurance premium of about £520. Several of the compensations on her list turned out to depend on the exhaustion they compensated for, and shrank along with it. None of this was heroic. It was the order of operations that mattered: the fixed costs came down before the income did, so that when the question was put to her she was able to answer it.
Here, then, is the alternative to the dated spreadsheet, and it might be called daily freedom. It has three moves, and Nadia made all of them. Reduce the fixed costs, because every pound of obligation is an hour already promised. Practise the life you say you want in small form, now, so that it exists somewhere other than on a list headed After. And turn some money into time in the present, without waiting to turn all of it into time at the end.
None of the three needs a glass meeting room. The first is open to almost anyone with a bank statement, and usually begins with the costs that were taken on to make an exhausting week bearable. The second costs nothing but nerve: twenty minutes of the thing on the list, this week, done badly. The third comes in every size, from a day a week down to a single errand that somebody else is paid to run. Taken in that order they also guard against the commonest way such changes fail, which is that a person cuts their hours in a burst of resolve, finds the bills unchanged and the free day shapeless, and is back at full time within the year, poorer and convinced that it cannot be done.
On that third move there is some evidence. In 2017 Whillans and colleagues published a study in the journal PNAS which surveyed 6,271 people in the United States, Canada, Denmark and the Netherlands, and found that those who spent money to save themselves time, on cleaning, deliveries or errands, reported higher life satisfaction than those who did not, and that this held after allowing for income. The same paper described a small field experiment in which sixty working adults spent forty dollars on something that saved them time and forty dollars on a material purchase. They reported better moods after the time-saving one. The limits should be stated with the finding. Sixty people and forty dollars make a small experiment, and the surveys included few respondents on very low incomes, so nothing here shows that someone short of money would be happier for spending it on convenience. What the study does suggest is that people with some slack tend to underuse it in this direction, buying objects where they could have bought hours.
How much work is enough? The useful form of the question is this: what is the least paid work that would cover a decent life, meet your responsibilities and keep your skills alive? Nobody can answer it for anybody else. For a great many people the honest answer is a full-time job, sometimes more than one, and that answer is not a failure of imagination. A decent life costs what it costs, children and rent are not lifestyle choices to be optimised away, and nothing is gained by pretending that four days a week is on offer to a warehouse shift or a zero-hours contract. The question earns its keep even so, because it separates the work a life needs from the work that merely accumulated on top, and most people who ask it find that the two are not the same amount.
One way to find your own figure is to build it from the bottom. Begin with what a decent month actually costs you: housing, food, the people who depend on you, something saved, something for pleasure. Then ask how many of your real hours, at your real wage, that sum comes to. The difference between that number and the hours you in fact work is the part of your week that is open to question. For some people the difference is nothing, or less than nothing, and what they need is a pay rise and not a philosophy.
Nor is the answer always less. Callum's working life is a standing reproach to the idea that fewer hours mean more freedom. He has had free Tuesdays for six years. He works when a client appears and does not when one fails to, gets up at ten, and can go a fortnight without anyone expecting him anywhere. Had you put the Tuesday question to him he would have had to admit that he was already living the answer, and that it consisted largely of his phone. What he lacked was the very thing Nadia had too much of. In December, some weeks after the walk home from Montpelier, he did something he had refused to do since his last salaried job and signed a six-month contract with a design agency near the harbour: Monday to Wednesday, in the office, at a day rate lower than he was used to quoting. For the first time in years he knew in December what he would earn in March. He also found, to his surprise, that he liked being expected. Somebody noticed whether he was in, and in his second week somebody saved him a seat.
The two of them moved in opposite directions and arrived at much the same place, three or four days of work that they had chosen, with edges. Enough is a quantity with too little on one side of it as well as too much on the other, and a life can be thin for want of obligation as surely as it can be crushed by a surplus.
Then there is Jo, and the chapter owes her some honesty. None of this is available to her. A teacher who drops to four days loses a fifth of a salary that is already fully spoken for, by a mortgage and two teenagers, and is likely to find, as Nadia's manager warned, that the marking does not shrink to fit. She cannot turn down a promotion that she has not been offered, or hand back a second account. She can make small purchases of time where the budget allows, such as having the big shop delivered, and they are worth making, but they are small. Her hours at school are not what own her in any case. She loves the job, on most days. What consumes Jo lies on either side of the school day, in the mornings and evenings and weekends that belong to everybody but her, and no arrangement with an employer will reach it. Her room will have to be found somewhere else, and she is not going to be able to find all of it by herself.
The announcement came round on a Tuesday in the second week of January, at ten past nine. The new director was a colleague of thirty-six, able and well liked, who would be very good at it and would be on the 6.15 the following week. Nadia read his name and felt the pang she had been expecting, exactly as sharp as she had feared and a good deal shorter. She wrote to congratulate him and meant most of it. On the Friday she woke at ten past six from habit, lay for a while listening to other people's cars start, and worked out that for the first time in eleven years nobody anywhere was waiting for her. Being a consultant, she got up and made a list. By nine she had seen that it was a mistake and put it in the recycling, and at half past ten she was sitting on the edge of the bed in the spare room, looking at a black fibreglass case that she had collected from Chorlton before Christmas and had not yet opened.