Chapter 4 of 10 · 9 min read
Practice, Not Fantasy
From The Practical Art of Living Free by Wrotebook
A carbon road bike weighs a little under eight kilos and will lean against a hallway wall for four years without complaint. Nadia's was matt grey with a thin red line along the top tube, and in the time it had stood between her front door and her kitchen it had acquired a film of dust on the saddle, a helmet hung from one brake lever and, over the handlebars, a tote bag full of other tote bags. She passed it eight or ten times a day, turning slightly sideways, and had long since stopped seeing a bicycle. It had become a piece of furniture with an opinion.
She bought it the week after a colleague's leaving drinks, at which three people she liked turned out to ride together on Sunday mornings, out through Cheshire to a café and back. The bike was the entry fee, or seemed to be: nineteen hundred pounds, and then the shoes that clip to the pedals, the pedals themselves, two jerseys, the padded shorts and a pump. She rode it twice. The first time was to Chorlton Water Park and home, alone, to practise falling off at junctions, which she duly did. The second was eleven miles with the Sunday group, who were kind and waited for her at the top of every rise, and that was worse than being left behind. In the winter she bought an indoor trainer, so as to get fit enough to go back. It is in the cupboard with the boiler.
Before anyone is hard on her, it is worth being exact about what she was trying to buy, because it was not a bicycle. She wanted Sunday mornings out of doors, a body that did something other than sit, and friends at work who were not about work. Every one of those wants is a good one. The purchase satisfied none of them, and it let her feel for a week or two as though it had.
Things done for their own sake are among the best that a life contains, and the British do a great many of them. When the insurer Aviva surveyed UK residents in 2023, 93 per cent said they had regular hobbies, and the Horticultural Trades Association found in 2024 that about 55 per cent of adults garden. Nearly all these pursuits need things. A garden wants a spade and somewhere to keep it, a choir wants folders of music, and anyone who has shared a house with a potter knows about the clay. Here is the strongest argument there is against owning as little as possible: a pursuit worth having generally requires tools, mess, repetition, failed attempts and storage. A shed of well-used tools is evidence of a life, and nobody should be talked out of it by a photograph of an empty shelf.
The difficulty arises only when the things stand in for the doing. Equipment is the one part of a hobby that can be acquired in an afternoon, and so it is the part we reach for when what we are actually short of is time, or nerve, or company. The kit then stays where it was put, as kit does, on behalf of a person who has not turned up yet.
Any pursuit places seven kinds of load on a life. Three are easy to see, namely the equipment, the space it occupies and the money. Two are easy to underestimate, which are the time it needs if it is to mean anything and the attention it either restores or scatters. The last two are the ones people prefer not to look at: the social load of whoever you do it with or measure yourself against, and the identity load, which is the question of whether you love the thing itself or want to be the kind of person who does it. Guilt tends to fasten on the first three. The truth is usually found in the seventh.
For the bike, the equipment and the money were considerable and beside the point. The time it wanted was Sunday morning, the one morning she had. The social load was a group whose kindness she experienced as assessment. And the identity load was nearly the whole of it, since what she had wanted was to be someone who rode with those three on Sundays, and owning the bicycle was as near as she could get without doing so.
There is a test for this, short enough to remember. Have I done it at least three times in the last three months? Do I come away from it more alive, by which I mean steadier, more capable, better company? And given a free afternoon and a hundred pounds, would I sooner go deeper into it or buy something more for it? The bike's answers were twice in four years, slow and observed, and an indoor trainer. She photographed it on a Saturday, listed it for eleven hundred pounds, and sold it on the Monday evening to a nineteen-year-old who had come on the tram with the cash in an envelope, checked the gears with obvious competence, and rode it away up the road standing on the pedals. She watched him as far as the corner. What she felt was less like loss than like having returned something borrowed.
The spare room held a harder case, in both senses. Her cello had stood in the corner behind the ironing board since the day she moved in, shut in the black fibreglass case her parents had bought with it when she was fourteen. She played from the age of nine until she was eighteen, reached grade seven, sat at the third desk of a youth orchestra, and stopped during her first term at university for no reason she could afterwards name. On the test's first question the cello does worse than the bike: not twice in four years but not once in twenty-three. Seen from the hallway, the two objects are the same mistake. Both are expensive, unused and in the way.
They are not the same, and the remaining questions show why. That Saturday she laid the case on the bed and undid the catches. The A string had gone, curled back on itself like a watch spring. The bridge was leaning, and the bow had shed half its hair into the lining. She tightened what could be tightened and drew the bow, badly, across the open C. The note was rough and it filled the room, and she felt it where cellists feel it, through the breastbone, and stood for some minutes afterwards with her hand flat on the wood. "More alive" is a vague phrase until it happens to you. As for depth, there was nothing she wanted to buy. What she wanted was a teacher and an hour.
The bike belonged to somebody she had hoped to be mistaken for. The cello belonged to somebody she had been, and missed. One is a fantasy self and the other a dormant one, and the whole use of the test is that it can tell them apart when their owner cannot. The audit's word for the cello is repair, which covers anything valuable whose relationship with you has broken down. On the Wednesday she left work at five, which was noticed, and carried the case up a flight of stairs to a workshop over a row of shops in Chorlton, where a man with glue on his cuffs looked it over, named a price for a new bridge, new strings and a rehaired bow, and told her to come back in three weeks. The hour, she thought on the way home, was going to be harder to find than the money, and it was not an hour that the 6.15 to Euston seemed likely to improve.
Jo's case looks at first like no case at all, because she has bought nothing. Her object weighs about five grams. It is a council form, Application for an Allotment Tenancy, printed off two springs ago, filled in with her name, her address and her first three choices of site, and never signed. It lives in the kitchen drawer underneath the takeaway menus. Her father kept a plot until the year he died, on a sloping site on the west side of the city, and her Saturdays as a child were spent on it, being paid in raspberries to pick stones out of the soil. She knows exactly what she would be applying for.
Put the test to Jo and it returns a blank, there being no plot to have visited three times. But the first question carries a rider that is worth as much as the other two together: if you have not done the thing, was there a real obstacle, or does it belong to an imagined self? For Nadia's bike the obstacle was imaginary. For Jo it is as solid as a timetable. An allotment wants several hours a week and her weeks contain none. The form is therefore no fantasy. It is a deferral, which is fantasy's more respectable cousin and does much the same job, since it allows a want to be kept indefinitely without being acted on.
There was a second reason, and she admitted it only when asked. Everything else in Jo's week is for somebody. The plot would be for her, and signing the form felt like taking something out of the common pot, which she had been brought up not to do. It was Ella, sixteen and unsentimental, who came across it while looking for a pizza menu, read it through, and asked why it had never gone. Jo said there would be a waiting list, years probably.
"Then you'd better get on it," Ella said, and went back to the menus.
Jo signed it against the fridge door and posted it on the way to school the next morning, before she could think of a reason not to.
Callum owns one thing of consequence, and it was not in the photograph of his room because it lives under the bed. It is a padded grey bag holding a camera body and three lenses, bought second-hand over four years for a little under three thousand pounds, and it stands for the photography business. The business has a name, a domain that he renews every February and a one-page website, which he built in an evening and which, this being his trade, is very good. It has never had a client. He last used the camera in earnest two summers ago at a friend's wedding, as a favour, and the pictures are still on the card.
What the bag is for becomes clear at parties. Asked what he does, Callum says that he builds websites but is moving into photography, and the person he is talking to says how interesting, and for the length of that conversation he is a man in motion. He has been saying it for four years. Put the test to the bag and he fails the first question outright, then passes the second in an unexpected way: he does love taking pictures, and takes dozens a week, on his phone, of the harbour in different lights. It is the third question that finds him out. In March he bought a portrait lens.
His is a particular kind of fantasy, and it suits a drifter exactly. Nadia's bike imagined a self with more in her life. Callum's lenses protect a self about whom nothing has been decided. So long as the business is about to begin it cannot fail, and neither can he, because he is not a web designer of thirty-four who rents a room; he is someone between things, and the bag under the bed is the proof. The lenses were never really for taking pictures. They were for the sentence.
It was Sam who said so, more or less, on the walk home from a birthday party in Montpelier in October, having heard the sentence delivered once again to a stranger beside the drinks table.
"You know you've been moving into photography the whole time I've known you."
Callum laughed and started on the usual account, which involved the right moment, a couple of portfolio pieces and the spring. He got about halfway. They had reached the bottom of the hill, and it was late, and he found that he could not finish it with a straight face.
"It's just a thing I say," he said. "At parties. I don't think there's a business. I don't think there was ever going to be one."
Sam walked on a few steps before answering.
"I know. I've been wondering when you'd notice."