Chapter 7 of 11 · 8 min read
The Pocket-Sized Market
From The Market for Your Mind by Wrotebook
The first sale of your day takes place before you are fully awake. The phone has spent the night on the bedside table, charging and, in its quiet way, working, and when you reach for it, which you do before you have quite decided to, the lock screen is waiting with a summary of everything that has been arranged for you while you slept. There is a message from your sister, sent after midnight. There are two work emails, one marked urgent by a colleague who marks everything urgent. A news alert about the weather. A shopping app with the information that something you once looked at is now slightly cheaper. A video service reporting that a channel you watched once in March has posted something new. A game you have not opened since the summer, announcing that your daily reward is ready to collect. And three alerts from a social app letting you know that people you half know have posted things, liked things, or would like you to know that they are thinking of you. It is eight minutes to seven. You are still lying down, and you have already been in the market for several minutes.
For most of the history this book has covered, the market had to wait for you to come to it. You had to sit down in front of the television, buy the paper, switch on the computer, open the browser, type something into a box. The market kept something like shop hours, and it had a front door you could close. The smartphone took the door off. Apple's iPhone arrived in 2007, not the first phone to reach the internet but the first to make doing so feel natural, a sheet of glass that responded to a finger. In July 2008 the App Store opened, and any company that could write software could put it into millions of pockets. In 2009 iPhone apps gained the ability to send push notifications, short messages that could appear on the screen, and make a sound, when the app itself was closed. Other phones followed the same course. Within a few years most adults in rich countries were carrying, everywhere and at all hours, a device that was always on, always connected, nearly always within reach, and able, at the discretion of several hundred companies, to tap them on the shoulder.
The tap is new. Television had to place its interruptions inside programmes you had chosen to watch. A banner had to sit on a page you had chosen to visit. Search had to wait for you to ask. A notification needs none of that. It can arrive in the middle of a meal, a meeting, a conversation, a film or a night's sleep, and pull your attention towards whatever its sender would like you to do next, without the app being open and without your being interested. The permission for all this was given, in most cases, in about a second, early in the relationship. When you first open a new app it asks whether it may send you notifications, at the moment you are most curious about it and least able to imagine how freely it will use the privilege. Most people say yes. A question put honestly, as a choice between hearing from this company a few times a week and hearing from it several times a day for the rest of your life, would get a different answer, which is why it is not put honestly. Turning notifications off is possible, app by app, several screens deep in the settings, at some calm moment when you remember to. The market learned long ago that whatever happens when nobody makes a choice is what happens to most people, and the companies sending the notifications know precisely how many people never make one, because they count them.
The most effective form of the tap is not even a message. It is a small red circle with a number in it, sitting on the corner of an app's icon. It says that something is waiting, three of something or twelve of something, without saying what, and it does not need to. It works on one of the most dependable features of human attention, the faint discomfort of an unfinished task, and it does so silently and continuously, every time you unlock the screen and see the row of icons with their little red demands.
The messages themselves are not written so much as grown. A company sending notifications to millions of people can send one wording to some of them and another wording to others, at different hours, and keep whichever version brings more people back. Over time the surviving notifications acquire a recognisable character. They are friendly, slightly anxious, and personal in a way that no person writing to a stranger would dare to be. They tell you that you have been missed, that someone has been thinking about you, that something is about to expire, that you are on a streak which it would be a shame to break. Each phrase has earned its place by moving a number, and the number is the share of people who opened the app within a few minutes of being told to. Nobody involved is under any illusion that the app has missed you. The app has noticed that you have not opened it, which is a different thing, and has a figure for what that is costing.
You get up. On the way to the kettle you clear the notifications without reading most of them, which is a small daily labour of its own. You answer your sister. You open the urgent email and find that it is not. While the kettle boils you open the social app to see what the three alerts were about, and some time later you are still there, the tea going cold, having watched a short video about a dog, another about a recipe, a third about a politician you dislike saying something you dislike, and several advertisements that were cut to the same length and rhythm as everything around them and that you could not now describe. On the train you read the news, then switch to a game, then go back to the social app. At work the phone sits face up beside the keyboard and lights up every few minutes, so you turn it face down, and it buzzes, and you look. At lunch you open the shopping app because of the morning's reminder, buy the thing that has become slightly cheaper, and then buy the thing the app suggested beside it. In the afternoon there are messages and videos between meetings, on the way home a podcast, in the evening a series on a streaming service with the phone in your hand during the slower scenes, and in bed the phone again, for longer than you meant.
None of it is unusual, which is the point. Ofcom, the British communications regulator, measured it in its Online Nation report, published in December 2025. In May 2025, it found, adults in the UK spent an average of four and a half hours a day online on their personal devices, phones, tablets and computers, not counting the television set. Among eighteen- to twenty-four-year-olds the figure was about six hours and twenty minutes. YouTube alone accounted for about fifty-one minutes a day. And more than half of all the time British adults spent online went to the services of two companies, Alphabet and Meta.
The phone, unlike any medium before it, is also a ledger. Nielsen once sent families small booklets and asked them to write down, for a week, what they had watched and who had been in the room, and the booklets came back full of guesses and question marks, because people are unreliable witnesses to their own attention. Your phone keeps that diary now, automatically, to the minute, with no question marks at all. Most phones will show you a weekly screen-time report if you go and find it: hours per day, minutes per app, how many times you picked the device up, how many notifications arrived. It is the most accurate account of an individual's attention ever kept, and it is kept not by whoever drew the short straw at the kitchen table on a Sunday evening but continuously, by the device itself. The households of the 1950s recorded their evenings for a researcher. You record your days for several hundred companies, and for yourself, if you choose to look. Read as a receipt, a fairly ordinary week might come out like this:
Paid out: messages from people you love; a map that found the right street in the rain; music on the train; the news; a recipe; a bus timetable; a bank balance checked in a queue; a video call in which your nephew showed you a tooth; four or five genuinely funny videos. Taken in: about thirty hours; some eighty pick-ups a day; several hundred notifications answered, swiped or ignored; your location, your contacts, your purchases and your pauses. Measured: daily active users, sessions, minutes per session, notification open rates, items per basket. Left behind: a morning that began before you were up, a cup of tea that went cold, and a vague sense, at about eleven at night, that the day had gone somewhere without you.
The first line is the longest, and it is the reason nobody throws the phone in the river. It is a telephone, a camera, a map, a library, a bank, a post office, a newspaper, a record collection, a translator, a torch and a window onto the faces of your family. People without one find ordinary life increasingly hard to manage, from paying for parking to booking a doctor's appointment. Many of the four and a half hours go on things that matter. The difficulty is structural. Every one of the hundreds of companies with an app on the phone has a reason to bring you back to it as often as possible, because every visit is attention that can be counted, priced and sold. Each, taken on its own, is asking for a moment. Together they are asking for the whole day, one moment at a time, on the same device you need for everything else. You cannot close the shop without closing the bank, the map and your sister.
There was one occasion on which the companies discovered that the shop was not theirs. With version 14.5 of its iPhone software, released on 26 April 2021, Apple began requiring apps to ask your permission before tracking you across other companies' apps and websites. A small box appeared, asking whether you would allow it, and offering a button that asked the app not to. Asked plainly, large numbers of people declined. In February 2022 Meta estimated that the change would cost it about $10 billion in revenue that year, an estimate of its own, and the following day its shares fell by about 26 per cent. The prompt was presented, accurately, as a gift to the user's privacy. It was also a demonstration of who owned the phone. For a decade, the apps on it had counted their users as though the device were neutral ground. It turned out that the company that made the device could decide, by changing a few lines of software, which of its guests were allowed to keep notes on the other guests, and the most valuable meter in the pocket changed hands overnight, from the companies that had built their businesses on it to the company that made the glass.
You are not obliged to do anything about any of it. But somewhere in the settings of the phone beside you there is a report on your last seven days, compiled to the minute and sent to nobody, which almost certainly contains a number you would not have guessed, and which you are the only person in the world who has no commercial reason to read and every other reason to.