Wrotebook

Chapter 1 of 11 · 9 min read

The Room Behind the Mirror

From The Market for Your Mind by Wrotebook

Six men are standing in the dark, taking notes on breakfast. They are in a narrow room on the ninth floor of an office building in Manhattan, some time in the middle of the 1950s, five of them from an advertising agency and one from a margarine company, and they are standing because nobody thought to put chairs in a room whose only purpose is to look through a wall. The wall is a large one-way mirror. On the other side of it, in a bright room furnished to resemble somebody's idea of a comfortable sitting room, eight women are seated in a half-circle of upholstered chairs. There is a low table with a plate of biscuits arranged by someone who expected them to be photographed rather than eaten, an ashtray beside every chair, and a coffee pot that a young man refills at intervals with the air of a waiter at a wedding he has not been invited to. The women have been told that the afternoon is about breakfast, which is true as far as it goes. Nobody looks at the mirror for long, because it is the kind of mirror that makes a person feel inspected, which is exactly what it is for.

The scene is a reconstruction. No single afternoon like it is documented here, and the women, the moderator and the notes are invented. The practice is not. In the decade after the Second World War, American advertising developed an appetite for what people felt about products as distinct from what they said about them, and a small industry grew up to feed it. Its best-known practitioner was Ernest Dichter, a psychologist who had trained in Vienna and who built a thriving consultancy on long, probing interviews about soap, cars, cake mixes and almost anything else that could be bought, on the theory that people's choices rested on hopes and anxieties they would not volunteer and might not recognise if they did. The trade came to be called motivation research. In 1957 the journalist Vance Packard published The Hidden Persuaders, an account of it that became a bestseller, and a good many readers learned, with a mixture of alarm and pleasure, that their feelings about margarine had been the subject of professional study.

The moderator is a pleasant man in a grey suit who smiles slightly more than the conversation requires. He asks what they put on their toast. Butter, says one, when the budget stretches to it. Margarine, says another, because the doctor mentioned something. A third says she uses whatever her mother used and has never given it a thought, and a ripple of laughter suggests she has spoken for the room. Then the blinds come down, a television set in the corner is switched on, and the women watch a commercial in which a knife draws a perfect yellow curl across a slice of bread in a kitchen roughly the size of a tennis court, while a mother whose children have never been near mud explains, in a voice of tremendous calm, that her family deserves the best.

When the blinds go up the moderator asks what they noticed.

"It looked greasy," says one.

"Her kitchen's bigger than my flat," says another, who has in fact said apartment, but the sentiment travels.

The moderator then asks the question the afternoon has really been arranged around, and asks it as though it had only just occurred to him. If this margarine were a woman, he says, what sort of woman would she be? It is the kind of question that motivation research favoured, because people who will not tell a stranger what they feel about themselves will happily tell him what they feel about an imaginary neighbour, and the women warm to it at once. She would be trying a little too hard, says one. She would have a kitchen nobody had ever actually cooked in, says another. She would be the sort of woman who exists only in advertisements, says a third, and the others laugh, because she has just described the commercial with more precision than the agency managed in its brief. Nobody says anything about margarine, and that is the point.

A woman in the corner, who has said nothing so far, says that she prefers the other brand because its packet looks more honest.

Behind the glass, pencils move. Someone writes APPETITE APPEAL LOW in capitals and underlines it. Someone else writes KITCHEN — ASPIRATION OR RESENTMENT? and draws a box round it, which is the moment at which a joke about floor space becomes a strategic issue. The man from the margarine company, who has spent forty minutes trying to look as though none of this concerns him, leans forward when the woman in the corner speaks, writes the word honest on his pad, and underlines it twice.

What happens in the bright room is a conversation. What happens in the dark room is the conversion of that conversation into something else, and the two rooms are not working from the same information. The women know what they said. They do not know what was written down, which remarks were judged significant, which were taken as symptoms of something they never mentioned, or what any of it will be made to mean in a report typed up three weeks later for people they will never meet. The division was also, in the manner of the decade, a division by sex: the people whose feelings were treated as raw material sat on one side of the glass, the people whose job was to say what those feelings meant stood on the other, and nobody at the agency would have thought the arrangement worth remarking on. The mirror lets light through in one direction only, and the arrangement it describes is older than the glass and has outlived it by a very long way: one side supplies the feelings, the other side keeps the notes, and the side that keeps the notes decides what the feelings were.

The notes have a future, which the afternoon does not. Within a month the commercial will be reshot with a smaller kitchen and a child who has been permitted a single grass stain. The packet will be redesigned to look more honest, which in practice means plainer lettering and less gold. A copywriter will be handed a brief concluding that the housewife wants reassurance rather than glamour, a finding none of the eight women expressed and few would have recognised, since what they said, more than once and in several forms, was that the advertisement did not look true; he will spend a fortnight trying to make a tub of yellow fat sound like a family doctor. None of the eight women will know that she contributed to any of this, and none will be asked whether the agency understood her. That is the genius of the arrangement, and its small chill. Nobody in the bright room is harmed by anything she can see. What changes is the thing that will later be aimed back at her, in her own front room, sharpened by what she gave away for a cup of coffee and an envelope.

The front room matters, because that is where the television set lived, and the set is the other half of the story. Its arrival in the American home in the 1950s was fast, and seventy years on it is easy to forget how much it brought with it. It gave a household an evening's entertainment every evening, at no further cost once the set was paid for. It gave news with pictures, sport without a ticket, comedy at a fixed time on a fixed night, and a whole country the novel experience of watching the same thing at the same moment and discussing it at work the following morning. In a great many homes it became the piece of furniture the other furniture was arranged around. In return it took the evenings themselves, hour after hour, in a shape regular enough to be scheduled. It took the family's attention at known times in a known room. And it took a permission no previous guest in the house had been given, which was the right to interrupt, several times an hour, with a message from someone who had paid to be there.

Setting what a medium gave beside what it took is a habit that repays acquiring, and it helps to give it a name. Call it the receipt. A receipt for anything that competes for attention has four lines: what it paid out to the people using it; what it took in from them; what it measured, meaning the number that stood in for their attention when the attention came to be sold; and what it left behind once the transaction was over. The receipt is not a verdict, and on television's the first line is long. It is simply the bill, which the people selling attention have always read with great care, and which the people whose attention it was have mostly been encouraged to leave on the plate.

The bill has grown. In 1971 Herbert Simon, an economist and computer scientist who spent his career studying how organisations make decisions, observed that information consumes something, and that what it consumes is the attention of the people receiving it, so that a wealth of information produces a poverty of attention. He was thinking about managers buried in memoranda rather than about margarine, and the remark has since been quoted by a great many people with a great deal of information to sell. But he had seen the shape of what was coming. When information is cheap and plentiful, the scarce thing is the attention needed to take it in, and scarce things acquire prices, and things with prices acquire markets.

This book is a history of that market, from the room behind the mirror to the sponsored line beneath a chatbot's answer, by way of the ratings meter, the banner advertisement, the search auction, the social feed and the telephone that spends the night beside the bed. Each wave looked new when it arrived, and was new in its details. Each began by giving people something they wanted, found a way to count the attention it gathered, turned the count into a price, and then competed for more of it with interruptions that grew louder, more frequent and better aimed. Once that sequence has been seen it is surprisingly hard to stop seeing, and the chapters that follow are mostly an exercise in looking.

What it adds up to is a market, one of the largest and least examined in the world, in which most people take part every day without having been shown the price list. The useful response to a market is not outrage, and it is not the industry's preferred response either, which is gratitude. Nor is it a weekend without the telephone, an experiment that tends to conclude on Monday at about twenty past eight. It is literacy: knowing what is being bought and sold, by whom and on what terms, so that a person can decide which transactions to be part of. The question to carry out of this room is a plain one, and it applies as well to a margarine commercial in the 1950s as to a notification that arrived this morning. What is being sold, to whom, and which number stands in for success?

In the bright room, the session ends at four. The women collect their coats and their envelopes and go down in the lift talking about the bus, the commercial and what the session had really been for, on which they have several shrewd theories, and by the time they reach the pavement the afternoon has already begun to settle into the category of things that happened on a Tuesday. In the dark room nobody has gone home. The lamp is on and the notes are spread across the table, and the account director reads them back aloud, one remark at a time, while the others decide what each one meant. Greasy becomes a problem of appetite appeal. The kitchen becomes a question of aspiration, settled after some discussion in favour of a smaller one. When he reaches the woman in the corner he reads her word out twice, and the man from the margarine company says that it was the most useful thing anybody said all afternoon, and that honest is what they will be selling in the spring, in a plainer packet, to her.